Where To Buy Pumpkin Pie May 2026

: Their recipe is often dairy-free (using tofu for texture), making it a popular choice for vegans or those with dairy sensitivities. Trader Joe’s : Offers a 9-inch pie for about $6.99 .

If you are looking for artisan-crafted pies delivered to your door, these bakeries are highly recommended by culinary experts. Achatz Handmade Pie Co. (Michigan) where to buy pumpkin pie

: Their traditional 12-inch pie retails for around $13.99 . : Their recipe is often dairy-free (using tofu

For a pie you can bake fresh at home anytime, look for these brands in your local grocery freezer aisle: Achatz Handmade Pie Co

: Often cited as a high-quality runner-up for those seeking specific dietary profiles.

These options are ideal for immediate pickup and offer a balance between quality and price.

Finding the right pumpkin pie depends on whether you value low cost and convenience or artisanal quality and unique flavors. Major retailers like Costco dominate the value market, while specialty platforms like Goldbelly provide access to award-winning bakeries across the country. Top-Rated Retailers & Grocery Chains